Can MAGA Conservatives Truly Follow Christ’s Teachings?
In an era defined by political polarization and cultural clashes, the relationship between modern conservative movements and Christian teachings warrants a critical examination. The socio-political landscape, particularly in the United States, displays an intriguing paradox where those who identify strongly with conservative ideologies—often under the banner of the "Make America Great Again" (MAGA) movement—also vocally embrace Christianity. This raises a pivotal question: can MAGA conservatives truly live in accordance with the teachings of Christ?
Historically, Christianity has been a force for profound social change. From the radical practices of the early Christian communities, who shared their possessions and supported the vulnerable, to the significant Christian influences on civil rights movements, the core message of Christianity seems deeply intertwined with progressive ideals of justice and equality. The key teachings of Christ emphasize love, compassion, and care for the marginalized—principles that might seem at odds with the stringent nationalism and often exclusionary rhetoric characteristic of MAGA conservatism.
In contrast to the inclusive message of Christianity, traditionalism, particularly in its more rigid forms such as Catholic Conservatism, often clings to the past. Historical instances abound where traditionalism has stifled progress and upheld social inequalities. The resistance of the Church against the heliocentric worldview during Galileo’s time serves as a poignant reminder of how clinging too tightly to tradition can lead one away from truth and compassion, which are also central tenets of Christianity.
Pope Francis, the current leader of the Catholic Church, represents a beacon of progressive values within a religious institution known for its conservatism. He has consistently emphasized care for the environment, compassion for refugees, and social justice—causes at the heart of progressive Christianity. His approach, which includes greater openness to dialogue and a less rigid interpretation of doctrine, contrasts sharply with the traditionalist inclinations of Catholic Conservatism, where rituals like the Latin Mass symbolize a longing for the past. While the beauty of tradition holds undeniable significance, an overemphasis on archaic customs risks overshadowing the vital societal relevance of Christ’s teachings in contemporary times.
The Latin Mass has become a cultural battleground within Catholicism. For some, it is a profound expression of divine mystery and ancient tradition. For others, it embodies an exclusionary dogmatism that alienates those who might otherwise be drawn to the living, breathing community of modern faithful. This tension mirrors the broader political landscape, where MAGA conservatism often revels in nostalgic visions that sidestep plights of the oppressed and overlook the evolving dynamics of society.
Progressive values, intertwined seamlessly with Christian teachings, invite a dialogue that embraces change and strives for inclusivity. These are principles that support the vulnerable and challenge structures of power that perpetuate inequality—tenets apparent in Christ’s actions and teachings throughout the Gospels. He consistently aligned himself with those on the margins, speaking against the hypocrisy of the Pharisees who prioritized law over love.
In the present context, issues such as economic disparity, racial equality, and immigration are modern equivalents of the concerns Jesus compassionately addressed. Yet, there is a marked incongruity when examining policies often celebrated by MAGA conservatives. These policies frequently favor economic systems supporting the wealthiest while neglecting the marginalized, casting doubt on their alignment with the Christ-centered focus on caring for the least among us.
The tension here is palpable: while individual conservatives may sincerely strive to follow Jesus’s teachings, their collective political stance might divert from these ideals. History suggests that when institutions prioritize power and preservation over progression and justice, they falter in embodying the transformative spirit of the Gospel. It is crucial, therefore, for Christian conservatives to critically engage with their beliefs and examine whether they foster dignity and love for all people—a clear mandate from the teachings of Christ.
The expectation isn’t a complete alignment with progressive ideologies, but rather an embrace of an adaptive faith that resonates with the world as it is today and how it should be—a world where justice and equality are not just aspirations but realities. This is an opportunity for MAGA conservatives, and indeed all Christians, to reconsider the guiding tenets of their faith. It is a call to action to manifest the compassion, humility, and inclusive love that Christ demonstrated, ensuring the essence of Christianity remains a force for good in an ever-changing world.
Ultimately, the pressing question is not whether MAGA conservatives can follow Christ’s teachings, but whether they are willing to adapt and embrace the change necessary for those teachings to truly shape a more just and compassionate society. This reflection offers a path not just for religious engagement, but for personal and communal transformation.